Dear Authors,
I have checked your reply to the comments given by one of the reviewers, and I solicit you to submit the revised manuscript, for a last review by the editor only.
My apologies for my delay in the answer.
Best regards
Guest Editor
Laura Peruzza

Dear Author,
I carefully checked your revised manuscript, and the answers given to Rew2 and I ask you additional modifications, that I hope, accomplishes the requirements of the scientific journal that is hosting this special issue. My comments are given in the annotated file here attach, here the main changes required;
1) I propose you a modification of the title and minor changes in the abstract
2) I ask you to modify the organization of the contents of introduction, moving the blocks of text now titled 1.2 and 1.3 after the first paragraph, page 1 line 28. Avoid subtitle if not absolutely necessary, move block 1.1 in the opening of chapter 2
3) reformat the descriptions of models in a bulleted list, if you want to separate parametric from modelling uncertanty use the second level title 2.1, otherwise upgrade 2.1.1 to 2.1 and so on
4) pages 9 to 11 have sometimes contradictions, it is difficult to understand why the logic tree is one branch only for some models, and the conclusions you derive from that. Perhaps explaining the reasons why you discarded the esploration of all the branches will help the reader to understand
5) figures have to be more readible in legends, avoid titles out of the frame of each panel, check the use of abbreviations
6) all the references marked with a double circles do not follow the standards of the journal, please check them and provide evidence of the restricted materials
7) I suggest that you quote explicitely the b-value used in Table 1, distance metrics adopted in Table 4.
Some colloquial and imprecise expressions are corrected in the annotated file.
Please send back the new version with tracked changes, I hope we can close the year with a final positive decision about your paper too.
Best regards
Guest editor Laura Peruzza

Dear Authors,
thanks for your new release, and sorry for my bad had-writing. There are some very minor typos and anomalies in the references, to be fixed with the technical staff in the proofing phase.

Hope to see your paper online ASAP
guest editor
Laura Peruzza