Dear Authors,
your paper has been revised by two reviewers. They raised several critical issues that need to be fixed before the publication. I think you should have a chance to propose a revised version of your work. My recommendation is to accept this paper after major changes.
In submitting your revised version, please provide a detailed list of the changes made to the text, and a detailed list of your responses to the reviewers’ comments.
Please note that this editorial decision does not guarantee that your paper will be accepted for final publication in NHESS. A decision will be made when the revised version will be available, and will be evaluated with the help of the same, or further reviewers.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli

Dear Authors,
your paper has been further revised by two reviewers. Moderate to major issues are still present in your work. My recommendation is to accept this paper after major changes. In submitting your revised version, please provide a detailed list of the changes made to the text, and a detailed list of your responses to the reviewers’ comments. Please note that this editorial decision does not guarantee that your paper will be accepted for final publication in NHESS. A decision will be made when the revised version will be available.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli

Dear authors,
two reviewers have further revised your paper, they suggested technical corrections at this stage. I agree with them. Also, I wish to congratulate on the interesting work you proposed. From my side I have an additional technical correction: an improvement of fig. 5 and fig. 8 is necessary. I would suggest making these clearer in details and dpi. Also I suggest, if it is possible, to post outside the figure the legends, avoiding the overlap with the background. Is it even possible to simplify the numbers of the legend with some decimal exponents? After these technical changes, in addition those suggested by the reviewers, the paper will be ready for publication.
Thank you for submitting your work to NHESS.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli