Dear authors,
your article has been revised by two reviewers who raised major critical issues. You provided a reply in the open discussion. I think you should have a chance to propose a revised version of the work. Therefore I decided to reconsider this paper after major revisions.
Please note that this editorial decision does not guarantee that your paper will be accepted for final publication in NHESS. A decision will be made when the revised version will be available and evaluated again with the help of the same or new reviewers.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli

Dear authors,
your article has been further revised by the same reviewer, who raised major issues at the first review stage; the reviewer is satisfied with the changes made and recommended accepting the work. I checked the work, and I think that your reply is suitable, also referring to the second reviewer's comments. The recommendation is to check the figure dpi when preparing the proof, paying attention to the units in the legends.
The paper is now ready for publication.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli