Dear authors,

thanks a lot for addressing very carefully the different comments by the reviewers. I consider that you have provided coherent response to the different issues raised by the two reviewers, so I would be happy to accept a revised manuscript in which you include the modifications that you have indicated in the response letters to both reviewers. I think it will not be necessary that the two referees review again the ms. so my decission is to publish subject to minor revisions, but you note that all the comidification indicated in the response letters must be contained in the revised manuscript.

Best wishes

Sergio M. Vicente-Serrano

Dear authors,

thank you very much for your submission. I think you have made strong effort responding the different reviewer's issues and improving the manuscript. I think your research is highly relevant and very well-presented and I am recommending the publication of the manuscript as is.

Thanks a lot
Best wishes
Sergio M. Vicente-Serrano