Dear Authors,
two reviewers raised, during the NHESS open discussion, moderate to major issues. I fully agree with them. My recommendation is to accept the paper after major changes. In submitting your revised version, please provide a detailed list of the changes made to the text, and a detailed list of your responses to the reviewers’ comments. Please note that this editorial decision does not guarantee that your paper will be accepted for final publication in NHESS. A decision will be made when the revised version will be available, and will be evaluated with the help of the same reviewers. I will provide a final editorial check then.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli

Dear authors,
two reviewers, the same who revised the paper at the first review stage, provided their feedback: minor to major changes. So, the paper still needs an improvement. Please provide all the suggestions raised. In submitting your revised version, please provide a detailed list of the changes made to the text, and a detailed list of your responses to the reviewers’ comments. Please note that this editorial decision does not guarantee that your paper will be accepted for final publication in NHESS. A decision will be made when the revised version will be available. I will provide a final editorial check then.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli

Dear authors,
only minor issues are now present in your paper. Please follow the suggestions raised by the reviewer. I will give a final editorial check before publication.
Best regards
Paolo Tarolli