Brief communication: Radar images for monitoring informal urban settlements in vulnerable zones in Lima, Peru
- 1Japan-Peru Center for Earthquake Engineering Research and Disaster Mitigation, National University of Engineering, Tupac Amaru Avenue 1150, Lima 25, Peru
- 2Graduate School of Civil Engineering, National University of Engineering, Tupac Amaru Avenue 280, Lima 25, Peru
- 3International Research Institute of Disaster Science, Tohoku University, Aoba 468-1, Aramaki, Aoba-ku, Sendai 980-8572, Japan
- 4National Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Resilience, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-0006, Japan
- 5Geoinformatics Unit, RIKEN Center for Advanced Intelligence Project (AIP), Tokyo, Japan
Correspondence: Luis Moya (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Lima, Peru's capital, has about 9.6 million inhabitants and keeps attracting more residents searching for a better life. Many citizens, without access to housing subsidies, live in informal housing and shack settlements. A typical social phenomenon in Lima is the sudden illegal occupation of areas for urban settlements. When such areas are unsafe against natural hazards, it is important to relocate such a population to avoid significant future losses. In this communication, we present an application of Sentinel-1 synthetic aperture radar (SAR) images to map the extension of a recent occupation of an area with unfavorable soil conditions against earthquakes.
Urban sprawl in Latin America has been influenced by people migrating from rural areas to the cities, which have produced high-density urban areas (United Nations, 2019). Informal settlement refers to the organization of people in search of housing who occupy unused land and perform collective actions to self-resolve their urban and social organization issues (Kapstein and Aranda, 2014). The urban growth in the capital city of Peru during the 20th century was mainly driven by informal urban expansion, which was motivated by the government policy of allowing people with low socioeconomic status to occupy unused land. Currently, the oldest informal settlements in Lima have obtained basic services, such as electricity and water. However, they are still vulnerable in terms of crime and security, accessibility, and natural hazards. In recent years, informal settlements have kept increasing countrywide. According to the Ministry of Housing, Construction and Sanitation (2021), 93 % of the urban growth in Peru between 2001 and 2018 consisted of informal settlements. Frequently, informal settlements occupy unsafe zones against natural hazards. For instance, Müller et al. (2020) showed that slum residents are more likely to settle in areas exposed to landslides than formal residents. Furthermore, during the Niño Costero phenomenon in 2017, 63 800 houses were destroyed due to river overflows. An economic loss of about USD 3124 million was estimated.
Remote sensing data have been used to extract information from urban and rural areas, such as land cover classification (Geiß et al., 2020), urban growth (Shi et al., 2019), and detection of damaged buildings (Moya et al., 2021). Regarding informal settlements, a comprehensive study of its spatial morphology can be found in Taubenböck et al. (2018). A further study to consider the temporal effects is reported in Kraff et al. (2020). However, remote sensing studies to identify spontaneous informal settlements consisting of makeshift shelters are scarce (Kuffer et al., 2016). The relevance of this task is the geolocation of such settlements to perform prompt prevention actions, such a relocation when the settlements are located in vulnerable areas.
This study shows how a simple, yet effective, time-series analysis of radar images from the Sentinel-1 constellation can map spontaneous informal settlements. We report a recent case in Lima, where a group of people settled in two hazardous unused land spaces. The rest of the paper is structured as follows. The following section reports a summary of the events that occurred in the two areas. Section 3 shows the time-series analysis of the radar images. Finally, our conclusions are drawn in Sect. 4.
The Lima metropolitan area faces very frequent critical problems regarding the illegal occupation of unused land and land trafficking. The most recent ones occurred in April 2021, when two large areas on the outskirts of Lima were informally occupied by citizens (Fig. 1). The people who participated declared to the local news that they were affected by the pandemic and could not afford their rents any longer. The Morro Solar, located in the Chorrillos district, was first occupied on 5 April 2021. Then, the Lomo de Corvina sector, located in the Villa El Salvador district, was occupied on 12 April 2021. According to the local news, about 5000 and 3000 people occupied the Morro Solar and Lomo de Corvina, respectively. During this sudden occupation, lots were delimited with chalk, and makeshift shelters were built with wooden sticks and plastic sheets (see Fig. 1e and f). It is worth mentioning that the government declared the Morro Solar an intangible area in 1977 and a historical monument in 1986. The police, in coordination with the local authorities, removed the inhabitants that participated in the invasions on 14 and 28 April in the Morro Solar and Lomo de Corvina, respectively, and the makeshift shelters were removed several days later.
The main concern this study addresses is that the occupied areas are unsafe against natural hazards. Luque and Núñes (2011) reported a geological evaluation of Inty Llacta, an informal settlement located close to the recently invaded area in the Morro Solar. The report referred to identified rockfalls and slope failure hazards, representing a severe danger to the inhabitants and buildings. Likewise, Medina et al. (2013) reported a technical evaluation of 29 informal settlements located in the Lomo de Corvina sector and pointed out that potential slope failure may occur in the areas referred to. It was also mentioned that the western part of the Lomo de Corvina, where the recent invasion was located, is the most critical area and is not suitable for urban development.
Regarding seismic hazards, seismic microzonation studies have been performed in metropolitan Lima, which included the implementation of field tests in the city's urban areas. Within the framework of these studies, the underlying soil deposits that conform to the capital city were classified into different zones depending on their mechanic and dynamic behavior. Thus, Zone I corresponds to the stiffest soil of the city and Zones IV and V to the most inadequate regions for being populated due to their particularly bad soil conditions. In the case of the Chorrillos district, it was divided into four zones, and the areas in the Morro Solar are categorized as Zone IV mainly because of the steep slopes that might fail under the effect of strong motions (CISMID, 2010). Furthermore, Lomo de Corvina is also classified as Zone IV due to the existence of deep eolian sand deposits and the largest fundamental vibration period found in Lima, which is slightly larger than 1 s (CISMID, 2011). Recent studies have shown that Lomo de Corvina might evidence important values of amplification factors due to the generation and interference of surface waves along the slope (Gonzales et al., 2019). It is worth mentioning that the collapse of the light makeshifts built during the recent invasions may not have represented an effective danger condition to the inhabitants. However, non-engineering masonry houses could have been constructed in the short term if the inhabitants were not removed. Note, however, that the sole action of removing shelters will exacerbate the need for residence.
This section shows how the informal settlements were observed from satellite imagery. Unfortunately, the areas of interest were cloud-covered on most of the days after the invasion. From the beginning of April 2021 until 5 May, only one product from the Sentinel-2 constellation (Copernicus, 2021) recorded on 20 April was cloud-free. On the other hand, synthetic aperture radar (SAR) images are designed to pass through the clouds; thus, we focus on SAR images from the Sentinel-1 constellation. A total of 14 Sentinel-1 SAR images, recorded from 3 December 2020 to 8 May 2021, were used for the analysis. The images were taken by the vertical–vertical polarization (i.e., vertical polarization of the incident wave emitted from the antenna and vertical polarization of the backscattered wave intercepted by the antenna) from the ascending path, and the incident angles at the two study areas are about 38∘. The SAR images were processed using the SNAP software (SNAP, 2021). Figure 1d shows a color composite of backscattered intensity recorded on different dates. The red band denotes an image recorded on 14 April 2021, and the green and blue bands denote the image recorded on 3 December 2020. Note from inset (ii) in Fig. 1c and d that the Lomo de Corvina area in the SAR image looks smaller than that from the optical image. Such geometric distortions are because of the oblique observation geometry of SAR images. Figure 2a depicts a scheme of the elevation profile corresponding to the line depicted in inset (ii) of Fig. 1. The profile is simplified by four segments, , , , and . In order to illustrate the geometric distortions in the SAR images, it is assumed that the range direction is parallel to the vertical plane that contains the profile. The slant range denotes the direction from which the microwave energy travels from the satellite to the ground. The microwave images are presented in ground-range format. Note that because points A and C share about the same distance to the satellite, both segments and occupy the same geographic position in the ground range ( and ) of the SAR image. In the optical image, the profiling scheme is located over the line (Fig. 1c); on the other hand, the profile is located along the segment in the SAR image, which is significantly smaller. However, the segment that contains the informal settlement in the optical image, , is only slightly larger than the length of . Note also that there is a shift between and .
Regarding the color composite SAR image shown in Fig. 1c, red tones are observed in the new informal settlements, which express an increment of the backscattering in time. Such an increment originates from the double-bounce scattering mechanism produced by the shelters. Figure 2b and c depict a scheme of the backscattering mechanism under two scenarios. When the radar pulses emitted by the satellite reach a flat area, only a small fraction of the energy is backscattered to the sensor (Fig. 2b). In the presence of an object (Fig. 2c), the radar pulses bounce off the ground towards the object, and then they are reflected from the object to the sensor. Therefore, a larger fraction of the energy is backscattered to the sensor. In the case of the new informal settlements, such objects are indeed the makeshift shelters. We exploit this pattern to map the extent of the occupied area. Figure 2d shows the time-series backscattered intensity at some representative points of the recently occupied areas (red lines) and existing built-up areas (blue lines). As expected, a clear increment is observed in the invaded area from 14 April 2021. Therefore, to map the recently occupied areas, a threshold for each pixel coordinate is computed. The threshold is set as the average plus 2 times the standard deviation of the time-series backscattering intensity until 2 April 2021. Then, if the backscatter intensity recorded on 14 April 2021 is greater than the threshold, it is assumed that the area is occupied. After thresholding, the morphological operators closing and opening were applied using a kernel size of 3×3. Then, pixel clusters were identified, and those with sizes lower than 200 pixels were filtered out. Figure 3 depicts the extent of the invaded areas in the Morro Solar and Lomo de Corvina. The black polygon shown in Fig. 3b denotes the extension of the occupied area, which is estimated from visual inspection of images and videos recorded by an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) (Inga, 2021b). Our results from SAR images identified 84 % of the area identified by visual inspection. Furthermore, only 67 % of the area identified from SAR images is contained within the black polygon. We believe that the main reason for the discrepancies between SAR images' results and those from visual inspection lies in the complex geometric distortions in the SAR images.
The results show that a recent squatter settlement could be identified from radar images. Considering the open access to Sentinel-1 imagery, this represents an opportunity to implement a sustainable, low-cost system to monitor informal urban growth over unsafe areas and perform hazard mitigation actions, such as relocation. Prompt measures can prevent significant losses to society. For instance, the mapped settlements are 438 000 and 265 300 m2 in the Morro Solar and Lomo de Corvina, respectively. From a visual inspection of the urban settlements nearby the recently occupied areas, we estimated a total of 3051 houses in the Morro Solar and 1595 in Lomo de Corvina that would have been exposed to strong ground motion amplification and potential landslides during earthquakes.
Informal urban growth is a recurrent problem in Peru that has increased in recent years. When the settlement is located in a hazardous area, an assessment of the extent of the occupation can be valuable for performing proper actions. In this study, we analyzed a recent informal settlement in two areas in Lima, the capital of Peru, through SAR images of 10 m pixel resolution. A time-series analysis was performed to identify increments of the backscattering intensity in the areas occupied by the settlements. An increment in the SAR intensity is observed from 14 April 2021, which is consistent with local media information regarding the dates of the invasion. We identified 438 000 m2 occupied in the Morro Solar and 265 300 m2 at Lomo de Corvina. One limitation is that the area identified at Lomo de Corvina is affected by the geometric distortions in SAR images. A future extension of this work will implement an automated monitoring system of informal settlements in unsafe areas against natural hazards. The monitoring system, constrained by the acquisition dates of Sentinel-1 images, can identify settlements within a few days. However, through a potential integration of other satellite constellations, a near-real-time monitoring system can be achieved. It is worth mentioning that this study focused only on the natural hazard aspects of informal urban growth, which might be a narrow view of the problem. We believe, however, that this study will be valuable for the authorities that must have a general view of the issue of informal urban growth.
LM, FG, CG, and MD conceived and designed the study. All the authors contributed in the analysis of the data, discussion of the results, and preparation of the manuscript.
The contact author has declared that neither they nor their co-authors have any competing interests.
Publisher’s note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This work was partly supported by the CONCYTEC–World Bank research program “Improvement and Extension of the services of the National System of Science, Technology and Technological Innovation” 8682-PE through its executing unit PROCIENCIA (contract 038-2019 FONDECYT-BM-INC-INV), the JSPS Kakenhi 21H05001, and the TCPAI Center and the Core Research Cluster of Disaster Science at Tohoku University (a Designated National University).
This paper was edited by Daniele Giordan and reviewed by two anonymous referees.
CISMID: Seismic microzoning of Chorrillos distric, available at: http://sigrid.cenepred.gob.pe/docs/PARA PUBLICAR/CISMID/Chorrillos Informe Microzonificacion Sismica MVCS-CISMID.pdf (last access: 4 May 2021), 2010 (in Spanish). a
CISMID: Seismic microzoning of Villa el Salvador distric, available at: http://sigrid.cenepred.gob.pe/docs/PARA PUBLICAR/CISMID/Chorrillos Informe Microzonificacion Sismica MVCS-CISMID.pdf (last access: 4 May 2021), 2011 (in Spanish). a
Geiß, C., Zhu, Y., Qiu, C., Mou, L., Zhu, X. X., and Taubenböck, H.: Deep Relearning in the Geospatial Domain for Semantic Remote Sensing Image Segmentation, IEEE Geosci. Remote Sens. Lett., 19, 1–5, 2020. a
Gestion: Policía inicia operativo de desalojo de familias que invaden zona intangible del Morro Solar en Chorrillos, available at: https://gestion.pe/peru/morro-solar-de-chorrillos-policia-inicia-operacion-de-desalojo-de-familias-que-invaden-zona-intangible-video-nndc-noticia/ (last access: 10 October 2021), 2021 (in Spanish). a
Gonzales, C., Sekiguchi, T., and Nakai, S.: Parametric Study on the Seismic Response of Two Contrasting Populated Slopes in Lima, Peru, in: Proceedings of the XVI Pan-American Conference on Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering (XVI PCSMGE), pp. 2009–2016, 17–20 November 2019, Cancun, Mexico, 2019. a
Inga, C.: Lima Peru. Zone known as `Lomo de Corvina'. People illegal invasion on land. Poor people and illegal land dealer, available at: https://www.dreamstime.com/lima-peru-zone-known-as-lomo-de-corvina-people-illegal-invasion-land-poor-dealer-april-th-aerial-media-over-dealers-image217502453 (last access: 20 October 2021), 2021a. a
Kapstein, P. and Aranda, E.: Las periferias interiores de Lima: localización e identificación de los barrios focos de vulnerabilidad. El caso de San Cosme, Revista INVI, 29, 19–62, 2014. a
Kraff, N. J., Wurm, M., and Taubenböck, H.: The dynamics of poor urban areas – analyzing morphologic transformations across the globe using Earth observation data, Cities, 107, 102905, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2020.102905, 2020. a
Luque, G. and Núñes, S.: Technical Report No. A6532: Geological-Geotechnical evaluation of rockfall in the Inty Llacta settlement, District of Chorrillos, available at: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12544/1706 (last access: 9 January 2022), Lima, Instituto Geológico Minero y Metalúrgico, 2011 (in Spanish). a
Medina, L., Gómez, D., and Benavente, C.: Technical Report No. A6637:Technical Inspection of Geological Hazards in Human Settlements of The Lomo De Corvina Sector, available at: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12544/1677 (last access: 9 January 2022), Instituto Geológico Minero y Metalúrgico, 2013 (in Spanish). a
Ministry of Housing, Construction and Sanitation: Presentación de nueva Ley de Desarrollo Urbano, available at: https://www.gob.pe/institucion/vivienda/informes-publicaciones/1846852-presentacion-de-nueva-ley-de-desarrollo-urbano (last access: 8 May 2021), 2021 (in Spanish). a
Moya, L., Geiß, C., Hashimoto, M., Mas, E., Koshimura, S., and Strunz, G.: Disaster Intensity-Based Selection of Training Samples for Remote Sensing Building Damage Classification, IEEE T. Geosci. Remote, 59, 8288–8304, 2021. a
Müller, I., Taubenböck, H., Kuffer, M., and Wurm, M.: Misperceptions of Predominant Slum Locations? Spatial Analysis of Slum Locations in Terms of Topography Based on Earth Observation Data, Remote Sensing, 12, 2474, https://doi.org/10.3390/rs12152474, 2020. a
Shi, L., Taubenböck, H., Zhang, Z., Liu, F., and Wurm, M.: Urbanization in China from the end of 1980s until 2010 – spatial dynamics and patterns of growth using EO-data, Int. J. Digit. Earth, 12, 78–94, 2019. a
Taubenböck, H., Kraff, N., and Wurm, M.: The morphology of the Arrival City – A global categorization based on literature surveys and remotely sensed data, Appl. Geogr., 92, 150–167, 2018. a
United Nations: World Urbanization Prospects: The 2018 Revision (ST/ESA/SER.A/420), United Nations, New York, 2019. a