Dear Authors,
many thanks for your response to the reviewers' comments.
Please submit a revised version of your manuscript addressing those comments.
The revised manuscript will be further reviewed by the editor and referees.
Best wishes
Carmine

Dear authors,
many thanks for having submitted your revised manuscript and for having addressed the reviewers' comments.

Please see below my comments and further comments by the reviewers.

Many thanks again for your contribution. I look forward to receiving the revised version of your manuscript.

Best wishes
Carmine Galasso

Dear authors,
many thanks for having submitted your revised manuscript and for having addressed the reviewers' comments.

As you can see below, Reviewers #3 wasn't satisfied with your response/revised manuscript. However, both Reviewers #1 and Reviewers #2 have recommended acceptance of the manuscript.

One of the reviewers suggests some revisions in light of the comments raised by Reviewer #3, to better highlight the novelty of your study.

Also, both I and an Executive Editor have noticed some poor presentation of illustrations (e.g., figures 5-6-7 without the appropriate legend of colours, missed scales; fig. 8 with a strange format according to international standard, etc). Please improve the quality of your figures.

Many thanks again for your contribution. I look forward to receiving a revised version of your manuscript.

Best wishes
Carmine Galasso

Dear authors,
many thanks for having revised your manuscript and having addressed my comments as well as the referees' comments.

It is a pleasure to accept your manuscript in its current form for publication in our special issue in NHESS. Congratulations!

I do note that the resolution of some figures is still low (e.g., Figure 2, 3 and 4); please upload high-resolution figures in your final manuscript before typesetting and proofreading.

Please follow the 'Manuscript preparation guidelines for authors' available at https://www.natural-hazards-and-earth-system-sciences.net/for_authors/manuscript_preparation.html.

In particular, figures 'must be submitted in *.pdf, *.ps, *.eps, *.jpg, *.png, or *.tif format and should have a resolution of 300 dpi or higher'. I don't think this is the case for your Figures 2 to 4. Also, please use consistent fonts (type and size) and colours in those figures.

Best wishes
Carmine