|
11 Mar 2013
Status : this preprint was under review for the journal NHESS. A revision for further review has not been submitted.
Reconstruction of the 1945 Wieringermeer Flood
O. A. C. Hoes , R. W. Hut , N. C. van de Giesen , and M. Boomgaard
The present state-of-the-art in flood risk assessment focuses on breach models, flood propagation models, and economic modelling of flood damage. However, models need to be validated with real data to avoid erroneous conclusions. Such reference data can either be historic data, or can be obtained from controlled experiments. The inundation of the Wieringermeer polder in the Netherlands in April 1945 is one of the few examples for which sufficient historical information is available. The objective of this article is to compare the flood simulation with flood data from 1945. The context, the breach growth process and the flood propagation are explained. Key findings for current flood risk management addresses the importance of the drainage canal network during the inundation of a polder, and the uncertainty that follows from not knowing the breach growth parameters. This case study shows that historical floods provide valuable data for the validation of models and reveal lessons that are applicable in current day flood risk management.
Received: 19 Feb 2013 – Discussion started: 11 Mar 2013
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
O. A. C. Hoes , R. W. Hut , N. C. van de Giesen , and M. Boomgaard
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
O. A. C. Hoes , R. W. Hut , N. C. van de Giesen , and M. Boomgaard
O. A. C. Hoes , R. W. Hut , N. C. van de Giesen , and M. Boomgaard
Viewed
Total article views: 1,530 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,004
423
103
1,530
96
101
HTML: 1,004
PDF: 423
XML: 103
Total: 1,530
BibTeX: 96
EndNote: 101
Views and downloads (calculated since 11 Mar 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Mar 2013
32
28
2
62
Apr 2013
9
17
3
29
May 2013
10
8
7
25
Jun 2013
2
1
3
Jul 2013
6
4
1
11
Aug 2013
2
2
0
4
Sep 2013
2
3
1
6
Oct 2013
1
4
0
5
Nov 2013
3
2
1
6
Dec 2013
1
5
0
6
Jan 2014
3
2
3
8
Feb 2014
3
3
3
9
Mar 2014
6
4
0
10
Apr 2014
6
8
0
14
May 2014
2
14
0
16
Jun 2014
13
1
14
Jul 2014
3
6
0
9
Aug 2014
2
10
0
12
Sep 2014
1
2
0
3
Oct 2014
2
0
2
Nov 2014
1
0
1
Dec 2014
2
4
0
6
Jan 2015
3
0
3
Feb 2015
1
0
1
Mar 2015
5
2
0
7
Apr 2015
8
1
0
9
May 2015
1
1
0
2
Jun 2015
5
1
0
6
Jul 2015
9
4
0
13
Aug 2015
2
4
2
8
Sep 2015
3
3
2
8
Oct 2015
3
1
0
4
Nov 2015
8
2
0
10
Dec 2015
1
0
1
Jan 2016
4
1
0
5
Feb 2016
2
8
2
12
Mar 2016
5
3
0
8
Apr 2016
1
14
0
15
May 2016
1
2
0
3
Jun 2016
2
3
1
6
Jul 2016
2
1
3
Aug 2016
0
Sep 2016
5
2
1
8
Oct 2016
1
2
0
3
Nov 2016
3
2
1
6
Dec 2016
4
0
4
Jan 2017
5
1
0
6
Feb 2017
3
1
0
4
Mar 2017
18
1
2
21
Apr 2017
15
2
1
18
May 2017
13
3
0
16
Jun 2017
10
2
4
16
Jul 2017
1
1
1
3
Aug 2017
2
1
0
3
Sep 2017
2
2
0
4
Oct 2017
1
0
1
Nov 2017
4
2
0
6
Dec 2017
7
1
0
8
Jan 2018
4
1
0
5
Feb 2018
12
4
16
Mar 2018
2
2
0
4
Apr 2018
3
4
1
8
May 2018
8
5
1
14
Jun 2018
4
3
1
8
Jul 2018
7
2
0
9
Aug 2018
4
2
0
6
Sep 2018
6
3
0
9
Oct 2018
4
2
0
6
Nov 2018
8
2
0
10
Dec 2018
6
4
0
10
Jan 2019
7
6
0
13
Feb 2019
5
1
0
6
Mar 2019
4
5
0
9
Apr 2019
3
0
3
May 2019
3
0
3
Jun 2019
3
2
0
5
Jul 2019
8
4
0
12
Aug 2019
8
3
0
11
Sep 2019
2
1
0
3
Oct 2019
2
0
2
Nov 2019
9
2
0
11
Dec 2019
6
0
6
Jan 2020
16
1
0
17
Feb 2020
8
1
0
9
Mar 2020
5
3
0
8
Apr 2020
0
May 2020
2
0
2
Jun 2020
8
0
8
Jul 2020
17
10
9
36
Aug 2020
7
5
5
17
Sep 2020
3
4
0
7
Oct 2020
3
3
0
6
Nov 2020
9
2
1
12
Dec 2020
7
8
1
16
Jan 2021
10
5
1
16
Feb 2021
5
5
0
10
Mar 2021
6
1
0
7
Apr 2021
4
2
0
6
May 2021
5
3
0
8
Jun 2021
4
3
0
7
Jul 2021
1
4
0
5
Aug 2021
6
1
0
7
Sep 2021
3
4
0
7
Oct 2021
1
2
0
3
Nov 2021
11
5
0
16
Dec 2021
8
4
1
13
Jan 2022
3
3
0
6
Feb 2022
12
0
12
Mar 2022
4
3
2
9
Apr 2022
8
2
1
11
May 2022
3
0
3
Jun 2022
4
4
1
9
Jul 2022
5
3
0
8
Aug 2022
2
0
2
Sep 2022
4
5
0
9
Oct 2022
9
1
0
10
Nov 2022
20
3
1
24
Dec 2022
7
3
0
10
Jan 2023
6
6
2
14
Feb 2023
9
3
1
13
Mar 2023
16
2
0
18
Apr 2023
6
1
7
May 2023
31
3
0
34
Jun 2023
28
2
2
32
Jul 2023
33
1
1
35
Aug 2023
40
3
3
46
Sep 2023
39
2
0
41
Oct 2023
30
3
3
36
Nov 2023
14
0
14
Dec 2023
13
0
13
Jan 2024
15
2
0
17
Feb 2024
12
1
3
16
Mar 2024
19
1
0
20
Apr 2024
8
1
3
12
May 2024
9
4
7
20
Jun 2024
19
2
1
22
Jul 2024
14
3
2
19
Aug 2024
19
1
0
20
Sep 2024
5
3
1
9
Oct 2024
10
1
2
13
Nov 2024
2
0
2
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 11 Mar 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Mar 2013
32
28
2
Apr 2013
41
45
5
May 2013
51
53
12
Jun 2013
53
53
13
Jul 2013
59
57
14
Aug 2013
61
59
14
Sep 2013
63
62
15
Oct 2013
64
66
15
Nov 2013
67
68
16
Dec 2013
68
73
16
Jan 2014
71
75
19
Feb 2014
74
78
22
Mar 2014
80
82
22
Apr 2014
86
90
22
May 2014
88
104
22
Jun 2014
88
117
23
Jul 2014
91
123
23
Aug 2014
93
133
23
Sep 2014
94
135
23
Oct 2014
94
137
23
Nov 2014
94
138
23
Dec 2014
96
142
23
Jan 2015
96
145
23
Feb 2015
96
146
23
Mar 2015
101
148
23
Apr 2015
109
149
23
May 2015
110
150
23
Jun 2015
115
151
23
Jul 2015
124
155
23
Aug 2015
126
159
25
Sep 2015
129
162
27
Oct 2015
132
163
27
Nov 2015
140
165
27
Dec 2015
140
166
27
Jan 2016
144
167
27
Feb 2016
146
175
29
Mar 2016
151
178
29
Apr 2016
152
192
29
May 2016
153
194
29
Jun 2016
155
197
30
Jul 2016
157
197
31
Aug 2016
157
197
31
Sep 2016
162
199
32
Oct 2016
163
201
32
Nov 2016
166
203
33
Dec 2016
170
203
33
Jan 2017
175
204
33
Feb 2017
178
205
33
Mar 2017
196
206
35
Apr 2017
211
208
36
May 2017
224
211
36
Jun 2017
234
213
40
Jul 2017
235
214
41
Aug 2017
237
215
41
Sep 2017
239
217
41
Oct 2017
240
217
41
Nov 2017
244
219
41
Dec 2017
251
220
41
Jan 2018
255
221
41
Feb 2018
267
221
45
Mar 2018
269
223
45
Apr 2018
272
227
46
May 2018
280
232
47
Jun 2018
284
235
48
Jul 2018
291
237
48
Aug 2018
295
239
48
Sep 2018
301
242
48
Oct 2018
305
244
48
Nov 2018
313
246
48
Dec 2018
319
250
48
Jan 2019
326
256
48
Feb 2019
331
257
48
Mar 2019
335
262
48
Apr 2019
338
262
48
May 2019
341
262
48
Jun 2019
344
264
48
Jul 2019
352
268
48
Aug 2019
360
271
48
Sep 2019
362
272
48
Oct 2019
364
272
48
Nov 2019
373
274
48
Dec 2019
379
274
48
Jan 2020
395
275
48
Feb 2020
403
276
48
Mar 2020
408
279
48
Apr 2020
408
279
48
May 2020
410
279
48
Jun 2020
418
279
48
Jul 2020
435
289
57
Aug 2020
442
294
62
Sep 2020
445
298
62
Oct 2020
448
301
62
Nov 2020
457
303
63
Dec 2020
464
311
64
Jan 2021
474
316
65
Feb 2021
479
321
65
Mar 2021
485
322
65
Apr 2021
489
324
65
May 2021
494
327
65
Jun 2021
498
330
65
Jul 2021
499
334
65
Aug 2021
505
335
65
Sep 2021
508
339
65
Oct 2021
509
341
65
Nov 2021
520
346
65
Dec 2021
528
350
66
Jan 2022
531
353
66
Feb 2022
543
353
66
Mar 2022
547
356
68
Apr 2022
555
358
69
May 2022
558
358
69
Jun 2022
562
362
70
Jul 2022
567
365
70
Aug 2022
567
367
70
Sep 2022
571
372
70
Oct 2022
580
373
70
Nov 2022
600
376
71
Dec 2022
607
379
71
Jan 2023
613
385
73
Feb 2023
622
388
74
Mar 2023
638
390
74
Apr 2023
644
390
75
May 2023
675
393
75
Jun 2023
703
395
77
Jul 2023
736
396
78
Aug 2023
776
399
81
Sep 2023
815
401
81
Oct 2023
845
404
84
Nov 2023
859
404
84
Dec 2023
872
404
84
Jan 2024
887
406
84
Feb 2024
899
407
87
Mar 2024
918
408
87
Apr 2024
926
409
90
May 2024
935
413
97
Jun 2024
954
415
98
Jul 2024
968
418
100
Aug 2024
987
419
100
Sep 2024
992
422
101
Oct 2024
1,002
423
103
Nov 2024
1,004
423
103
Latest update: 18 Nov 2024